CSI Poverty Simulations

Community Services, Inc. held two poverty simulations at Northwest Missouri State University for Education major students and one for the community of Maryville, MO.  Below are two articles from the Maryville Daily Forum and the Nodaway News Leader about the Poverty Simulation that was held at the First Christian Church in Maryville, MO on May 20th, 2004.

Area citizens meet to discuss poverty concerns

ROCHELLE SHIMAK-Forum Reporter-rshimak@classicnet.net

More than 637,000 Missourians are living at or below federal poverty level, according to the state's 2000 census. An additional 989,702 individuals have incomes just above the poverty level. These total more than 1.6 million Missourians struggling to meet their basic needs.

To help make the communities aware of the great need in Missouri, Community Action Agencies across the state have held Poverty Simulations to help others get a closer look at what it may be like to live on the poverty level.

On Thursday, Nodaway County area citizens met at the First Christian Church in Maryville to take part in their own simulation.  During the event, participants assumed the roles of more than 10 families facing poverty. Some were newly employed, some were recently deserted by the bread-winner and others were recipients of TANF(Temporary Assistance for Needy Families), either with our without additional earned income. Others were senior citizens receiving Social Security or grandparents raising their grandchildren. The task of the psuedo-families was to provide for basic necessities and shelter during the course of four 15-minute weeks.

Those that played the roles of the families were seated in groups in the center of the room where they each role-played the assigned families, some even were to act like children and discussed and worked as a family to provide for their needs.

Around the perimeter there were tables representing community resources and services for the families to take advantage of to help them function such as a bank, shopping center, Community Action Agency, employer, utility company, pawn broker, grocery, Division of Family Services office, payday and title loan facility, mortgage company, school and child care facility.  Volunteers, some of whom are actually facing poverty, played the roles of those at the resource tables. Volunteers were also recruited to assume the roles of a police officer and an illegal activities person.

At different times during the simulation, families may have been given news that could have been good or bad, such as the school water pipes busting, winning the lottery or being evicted from their homes because of unpaid rent.

"This project was geared to help people understand the complexities and frustrations of living in poverty," said Kim Heriford, Nodaway County Director of Community Services. "We do realize that experiencing a few hours of simulated poverty will not show all aspects, but the goal was to sensitize participants to the realities faced by low-income people everyday."

"The simulation participation was wonderful," Community Services Director Jodi Allen said. "I hope this experience has provided our community members with the knowledge they need to get more involved with the fight against poverty."

Poverty is a full-time job


“It was overwhelming.”

“I have never been so tired in my whole life.”

These were some of the comments made after the Community Action Poverty Simulation held on May 20 at the First Christian Church in Maryville.

The simulation, from Missouri Association for Community Action out of Jefferson City, is designed to help people understand the realities of poverty.

Hosted by the Community Services Inc., approximately 40 Maryville residents and 20 volunteer staffers participated in the role-play.

The staffers were made up of people with real life experience facing poverty. Drawing from those experiences, staffers portrayed quick cash employees, pawnbrokers, mortgage, rent and utility collectors. Others role-played bankers, employers, grocery clerks, schoolteachers, childcare providers and Department of Family Services caseworkers. Their history of encounters with those agencies lent a substantial air of authenticity to their role-play.

As one staffer, Rose, expressed, “It’s really rough, and it’s a day-to-day living process for many of us.”

Poverty Scenarios

The participants were divided up into various scenarios of families facing poverty. Some families were newly unemployed after many years of stability, some were recently deserted by the main breadwinner and some were recipients of Temporary Assistance for Needy Families. Others were senior citizen grandparents living on Social Security who found themselves raising their grandchildren.

The simulation covered a month in these people’s lives, broken down into 15-minute weeks. Each family had to decide how to navigate the crippling money crunch they were facing. They had to negotiate with old employers, DSF workers, pawnbrokers, banks, landlords and schools.

They had to figure out how to pay for transportation to and from the various agencies they needed to contact. They had to try and find time outside of their working hours, for the lucky few who still had employment, to get to these agencies before they closed.

Sometimes they needed to make decisions between prescription drugs for family members, or food.

And, they had to live with the consequences of their choices.

Keep records

One family decided to go the route of getting quick cash via a title loan. They made their payment, in cash, but didn’t get a receipt. The next time they showed up to make a payment, they were told there was no record of their previous payment. No amount of arguing, pleading, bluster or cajoling helped them. They didn’t have a receipt, period.

In the middle of this, an “illegal activities person,” or thief, roamed the environment. She entered homes while families were out and stole the money they’d left out in plain sight.

She preyed on teenagers, and talked them into the earning cash by doing drug deals for her.

Other children, lacking their medication, became disruptions in class.

Some families found, in a short period of time, their homes were foreclosed and they had nowhere to eat, shower or sleep.

End of their tether

The debrief, or comments after the simulation, were eye-opening as well.

A family who said, “we survived,” were met with the reality from the grocery store that, while they might have thought they survived, they’d only spent a grand total of $5 on food for the month.

Most agencies have a time limit between when a person applies for assistance and when they can receive it.

“There is a time lag. By the time they show up, they’re already in dire need,” a staffer explained. “When they get to one of our offices, they are hurting. They’re told their job has been eliminated, that’s a reality for many of us. It’s easy to see why people get upset.”

Department of Family Services staffers talked about being unable to hedge on the eligibility requirements. They’re down in black and white, without gray areas.

“There are hoops we have to jump through too. Sometimes we are just as frustrated with the system,” said another staffer.

Families facing the state of poverty deal with the pressures and difficulties of acquiring resources just to meet their basic needs; the emotional stresses that come with lack of sleep, lack of medication, lack of food. There is also the guilt that comes from being unable to provide their children with the medication they need. The children find their parents tired, frustrated and in some cases, unable to cope. They’re left to their own resources.

Bottom line, many people facing poverty today never expected to find themselves there. They are ambitious, they have dreams, hopes and accomplishments to build on.

Or, as Tammy West, employment and training director for Community Services, Inc. said so eloquently, “We are a community, they are us.”

By Karen Jones

 

If you would like to help during our next Poverty Simulation, please contact Kim Heriford or Jodi Allen at Community Services, Inc. 660-582-3113.